The story starts in the Harris apartment where Trina is playing around with Tori's Cuddle Me Cathy doll when Tori walks in
"Trina what are you doing to my doll?" Tori asked
"Relax Tori." Trina says
"Give it to me." Tori said
"No." Trina says
Tori tries to grab her doll back only for Trina to rip it in half
"Are you f*cking kidding me!" Tori yelled
"Oh relax." Trina said
"No! That was my favorite doll and you know it! You always ruin everything. Why did you think no one likes you in school! I wish you were never born!" Tori says
Tori runs off
"Wow." André said
"It was just a doll." Trina says
"Wasn't that the first doll she got?" Sinjin asked
"She's 29. She's too old for dolls." Trina replied
"Trina she cared a lot about that doll!" André yelled
"We can get it fixed." Trina says
Tori runs into her bedroom, slams the door and cries in her bed
"Tori." A guy says
Tori looks up and sees a guy in her room
"Who are you?" Tori asked
"My name is Mitch." Mitch replies
"Why are you here and how did you get into my apartment?" Tori asked
"I'm here to show you what the world would be like without your sister." Mitch replies
"It better be fun." Tori says
"Just come with me." Mitch says
Mitch takes Tori to an alternate world with their apartment being different
"Whoa our place looks different." Tori said
Tori looks around and doesn't see any pictures of her friends on her wall
"Hey where are the pics of my friends?" Tori asked
"You have no pics of your friends because in this world they aren't your friends." Mitch replies
"Huh?" Tori asked
"With Trina not being born, you never got into Hollywood Arts so a lot of stuff hasn't happened." Mitch said
"Like what?" Tori asked
Mitch takes Tori to the Los Angeles State Prison
"Why are we at the state prison?" Tori asked
"Because since you never got into Hollywood Arts, you never helped them pay the bill for that ping pong scam so they're all in jail for theft." Mitch says
The camera pans to a cell where the others, sans Trina and Robbie are in jail
"I can't stand being in jail." Alternate Cat said
"This is all Robbie's fault." Alternate Jade says
"Yeah he was the one who ordered that dip." Alternate André says
"We wouldn't be here if it weren't for him." Alternate Beck said
"Thanks for pointing that out Beck!" Alternate Jade yelled
"How long are they in there for?" Tori asked
"Well the scam was 13 years ago and they were sent here for 20 years so they have 7 years left. Jade and Beck aren't even together anymore since Jade never asked you for help." Mitch says
"Wait what happened to Robbie?" Tori asks
"He's dead." Mitch replies
"He's dead?" Tori asks
"Since you didn't go to Hollywood Arts, you never donated blood to him to save his life so he passed away back on May 14, 2011." Mitch said
"That was over 12 years ago!" Tori yelled
"Yes you have clearly pointed that out!" Mitch yells
"I wish Robbie was here." Alternate Cat said
"Well he's not! He died over 12 years ago because no one cared to donate blood to him so get the f*ck over it!" Alternate Jade yelled
Alternate Cat starts crying like a baby
"I wish you could stop being mean to everyone." Alternate André says
"Yeah well I wish we could break out of prison but that's never going to happen!" Alternate Jade yelled
"Neither is us getting back together!" Alternate Beck yelled
Beck and Jade stick their tongues out at each other
"Oh my. Wait are they able to sing at Karaoke Dokie?" Tori asked
"Nope you never performed so they are still banned to this day. Now speaking of singing, André's music carrier ended due to that Diddly bops incident. " Mitch says
"No he's a great singer. Hang on, what are the whereabouts of Cat's friendship with Sam?" Tori asked
"Since Cat's locked up for 20 years, she never met Sam so they never became roommates. With that, she and Sam never me and never starting their babysitting service. Sam is still in her biker gang." Mitch said
"No Sam was a great friend to Cat. Well besides her lying to her grandma about her staying in Phoenix for two weeks." Tori says
"Do you know what the worst part is?" Mitch asked
"Do I even want to know?" Asked Tori
"Jade's play Well Wishes was never produced." Mitch replied
"No this can't be true." Tori says
"Also because they were never your friends, they never helped you expose that Ryder guy and you never met iCarly to bust that Steven guy." Mitch said
"No I hate Steven! He's a lying cheater a*s son of a b*tch!" Tori yelled
Mitch shows Tori that her alternate self is married to Steven
"Happen 12 year anniversary honey!" Alternate Tori said
"Same to you, babe." Alternate Steven says
"AHHHHHH!" The real Tori yelled
"Don't you see, Tori? You need Trina and deep down she really needs you." Mitch said
"You're right. Thanks Mitch. Now take me back to the present!" Tori says
Tori wakes up seeing it was all a dream
"It was all just a dream? I need to talk to Trina!" Tori yelled
At that moment, Trina walks in with a new doll with
"Hey sis." Trina said
"Trina!" Tori yells
Tori hugs her sister
"What's this for?" Trina asked
"I'm sorry for saying I wished you were never born. I need you and I know you need me." Tori said
"It's cool. I have something for you." Trina says and hands Tori her doll
"You got me a new doll?" Tori asked
"No I got it fixed up. Well André and Sinjin helped." Trina replies
"Hehe." André and Sinjin said at the same time
"Trina, you know you might be crazy but I love you." Tori said
"Love you too sis." Trina says
"Kind of weird that you still have a doll since you're 29." Sinjin says
"Sinjin!" Tori yelled
"Didn't we just have a talk about this?" Trina asked
"Besides Cat still has her purple giraffe." André replied
"Cat's special so it makes sense." Tori said
The End
Ending Tagline: "He's a lying cheater a*s son of a b*tch!" -Tori